Living on your retirement savings can be a constant balancing act: between maintaining your standard of living and making sure you don’t outlive your savings. How do you know if you’re withdrawing too much from your financial portfolio and threatening your ability to enjoy life as you age? Or maybe you’re taking out too little, refraining from the kind of activities you desire, such as traveling, only to end up with more than adequate assets when you die. There are no easy answers to this dilemma, although retirement experts offer a few suggestions.
The 4 Percent Rule
this formula, retirees add up their retirement savings, such as 401(k)s
and IRAs, and then withdraw 4 percent of the portfolio’s overall value
in the first year of retirement. The next year, the retiree takes out
another 4 percent plus the rate of inflation, and so on. Although it’s
called the 4 percent rule, the typical withdrawal range is between 4 and
similar method is to base withdrawals on the value of the financial
market. One expert found that withdrawing at a rate around 5.5 percent
when markets are strong and reducing the withdrawal amounts when times
are tough is a better standard than withdrawing at a fixed rate.
offer another simple way to withdraw retirement funds because you’re
promised the same income payments for life. However, most annuities
aren’t inflation adjusted, which means your payments won’t keep up with
inflation. Plus, if you die early, you may forfeit any money left in the
annuity. One other drawback to an annuity is that your money is tied up
in investments, preventing access to emergency cash.
Another fixed approach is to base your retirement withdrawals on your life expectancy. The Social Security Administration provides
tables that give averages. Of course, you need to keep in mind your
health and your genetic disposition toward life-threatening diseases
such as cancer.
its simplest form, to figure out how much you could withdraw each year,
divide your savings/investments by your remaining years. For example,
if your life expectancy is 20 more years, you could withdraw
one-twentieth every year. However, if your assets keep growing, you
might have more left than you planned, and that money may have been
better used when you were younger and more active.
Market Watch advocates
a slightly different approach. The “Safety First Withdrawal Idea”
focuses first on what you need to maintain your standard of living
during retirement and then matches your financial resources to your
required expenses. The basic idea is to use conservative investments to
preserve your standard of living, such as U.S. Treasury Inflation
Protected Securities (TIPS), lifetime annuities from blue-chip issuers
and federally insured savings accounts. Social Security is a key part of
this type of safety-first portfolio, because the retirement benefits
are guaranteed and predictable. Once you’ve created an income plan from
your conservative investments, you can invest your remaining money in
riskier funds. If you get good returns, you can spend that money on more
More Flexible Approaches
Morgan Asset Management recommends a more flexible approach to
retirement withdrawal strategies. Rather than sticking to one formula,
the asset manager suggests reacting to changes in wealth, age and income
streams by periodically adjusting withdrawal rates and portfolio asset
allocations (Investment News). For example, as a retiree gets older or has maintained her assets, she could raise her withdrawal rates.
figure out the ideal withdrawal rates for each age, J.P. Morgan’s model
weighs five factors: the individual’s preference for timing and amount
of withdrawals, lifetime income, current age and life expectancy, the
predictability of the market and extreme events, and the retiree’s need
to spend the money.
The website Can I Retire Yet recommends
a withdrawal system that sells in response to your own “routine income”
needs rather than in response to market events.” The “total return
approach” or “active safe withdrawals” concept means selling some of
your most appreciated assets once or twice a year, when the money is
is where asset allocation comes into play,” writes Darrow Kirkpatrick.
“For me, it makes no sense to live off your conservative cash and bond
buckets when stock markets are up. That’s like dipping into the
storehouse when there is fresh, healthy grain available in the fields.
Much better to be selling volatile equity assets when they are in favor,
and to preserve your safe ‘buckets’ for the bad times.
those bad times come, as they inevitably will, then the flexible
withdrawal approach begins dipping into the safe cash and bond buckets
that have been set aside.” He says new research suggests that it may be
better to spend bonds first, which goes against traditional advice,
producing a rising equity allocation for the long term. In fact,
continuing low interest rates mean retirees are no longer depending on
bonds, as they once were.
Kiplinger.com dubs a similar approach in “lifestyle-driven investing.” Erin Botsford, a financial planner in Frisco, Tex., and author of The Big Retirement Risk, urges clients to divide their expenses into four categories: needs, wants, likes and wishes.
she recommends relying on “lifestyle investments”—those that produce
income, either now or in the future, and are safe, predictable or
guaranteed—to cover basic needs. “Food and shelter take a higher
priority than vacations and luxury cars,” she says. “Shouldn’t your
investment plan reflect this reality?”
your current savings aren’t enough to support your projected retirement
lifestyle, you may have to forgo some of your wants, likes or wishes,
or be willing to save more or work longer to afford them, she says.
the end, most of us will borrow bits of different withdrawal systems to
create what works best for us and adjust our retirement plans and
withdrawals according to our own set of circumstances—whether it’s poor
or good health, still-dependent adult children or the urgent need to
live in a warm climate.
Calculators and Simulations
You can plug your figures into various retirement withdrawal calculators and simulations. Here are a few:
Vanguard’s tool determines
how much you can withdraw each month based on how much you’ve saved,
your asset allocation (whether conservative, moderate or aggressive),
how long you expect to spend in retirement and which withdrawal method
you plan to use.
you plug in those figures and answers, its interactive tool shows how
much money you could have withdrawn from your portfolio during the time
the returns were calculated, using the dollar-adjusted withdrawal
method. In general, Vanguard suggests making withdrawals at rates no
greater than 3 percent to 5 percent at the outset of your retirement,
depending on your withdrawal method.
E*Trade Easy Retirement Calculator asks
for your expected age of retirement, how much you’ll get in Social
Security, your assets (savings and investments), your investment status
(conservative to aggressive) and an estimate of how much you’ll have
when you retire. After you input your retirement monthly expenses
(mortgage, healthcare, home expenses, etc.), the tool produces a
retirement plan comparing how much you’ll need versus how much you’ll
Monte Carlo Retirement Calculator factors
in market volatility, running random iterations, so you can see your
chances of meeting your goal. To determine your goal, provide your
desired annual withdrawal amount and the number of years you want the
account to last. The outcome, which is slightly different each time you
perform the exercise, shows your chances of failure and success.
“4% withdrawal rate in retirement unrealistic in real world, researchers say,” February 2014 Investment News
“Easy Retirement Calculator,” E-Trade
“Monte Carlo Retirement Calculator,” Money Chimp
“New Strategies to Ease Into a Secure Retirement,” March 2012 Kiplinger.com
“Retirement Withdrawal Strategies,” December 2013 Can I Retire Yet
“The ‘Safety First’ Guide To Retirement Withdrawals,” September 2013, Forbes Next Avenue
Living Within Your Means—and Assets was featured in the May 2014 Senior Spirit newsletter.
Blog posting provided by Society of Certified Senior Advisors